The holiday season is here, and what better way to spend your break than plunging into the world of secrets, suspense, and edge-of-your-seat surprises? This list is your ultimate guide to the most thrilling mysteries on Disney+, guaranteed to throw curveballs you shouldn’t miss (don’t worry—no spoilers and no frustrating bitin feelings).
With these binge-worthy mystery shows, you won’t need to wait week-to-week to uncover the next jaw-dropping moment. Whether you’re unearthing hidden treasures, decoding cryptic clues, or getting to the bottom of conspiracies and theories, every unexpected turn is just a click away. And with the extra time the holidays bring, there’s no better excuse to dive headfirst into these addictive worlds.
So settle in and let the unraveling begin—these mystery shows are calling!
LOST
4, 8, 15, 16, 23, 42. Play these numbers at the lottery and you might just find yourself caught in a web of events that change your life—whether you’re ready or not. That’s what happened to a passenger of Oceanic Flight 815 before crashing on an island full of danger and dark secrets and meeting individuals who will alter each and every one’s fate.
This isn’t just a place to survive. It’s home to strange creatures, cryptic and interconnected characters, and a force no one can explain. As everybody fights for survival, they must also uncover the truth behind the island’s origins. What is its purpose? And who (or what) is pulling the strings behind the terrifying mysteries? All will be revealed in time—through flashbacks AND flash-forwards.
National Treasure: Edge of History
The hunt for a long-lost treasure leads to hidden secrets, encrypted clues, and an ancient conspiracy. When a young adventurer discovers her family’s mysterious past is linked to a treasure hunt that could rewrite history, she’s thrust into a dangerous race to uncover the truth. Along the way, cryptic messages and historical puzzles reveal connections to one of the world’s greatest mysteries: the Amber Room, the fabled “eighth wonder of the world.”
As shadowy figures close in, the protagonist must navigate the secrets of her lineage, decipher encrypted clues, and outwit a secret society with its own hidden agenda. But as the stakes rise, one question looms: What is the true cost of unearthing a treasure that could change the course of history forever?
Connect
What would you do if you could see through the eyes of a serial killer? For one man, this nightmare becomes reality when his extraordinary regenerative abilities make him the target of a sinister experiment. Kidnapped and unwillingly connected to a ruthless murderer, he’s forced to witness the killer’s gruesome crimes as they unfold.
With each memory, a chilling question arises: Who is the killer, and what is his ultimate plan? As the disappearances of innocent victims escalate, the protagonist must race against time to expose the mystery of their connection. But with every step closer to the truth, the lines between victim, hero, and prey blur.
Secrets of Sulphur Springs
Imagine uncovering a portal to the past in a hotel with a chilling, haunted history. For a group of teens, this discovery spins their world upside down as they unravel secrets buried in time. When they stumble upon the mystery of Savannah Dillon’s disappearance, they realize the key to solving it lies in traveling to the past—but meddling with time always comes with risks.
As the teens dive deeper into the supernatural, the Sulphur Springs hotel reveals its tragic secrets. What happened within its walls, and why does the ghostly presence linger? With every trip through the portal, the stakes grow higher. Can they fix the mistakes of the past without unleashing more chaos—or making things even worse? A heart-pounding mix of mystery, time travel, and ghostly intrigue, this series will have you second-guessing every twist and turn.
Once Upon A Time
What if your favorite fairytale characters were living in our world but had no memory of their magical pasts? In the quaint town of Storybrooke, fairytales collide with reality in a thrilling story of curses, love, and redemption. Snow White, Rumpelstiltskin, the Evil Queen, and more must grapple with their hidden histories as they slowly start to remember their true identities.
Who cast the curse that trapped them in this world—and why? Can true love break its spell, or is the cost of freedom too great? As magic creeps back into their lives, alliances are tested, heroes fall, and villains face the chance for redemption. Once Upon a Time redefines fairytales with mysteries, twists, and emotional depth that’ll have you rooting for heroes and villains alike.
Grid
In a world shielded by a mysterious “grid,” everything seems under control—until one woman’s sudden disappearance sparks a chain reaction of questions that could unfurl the very fabric of this protective force. As investigators dig deeper, they discover that the grid isn’t just a shield—it’s a key to something far darker.
Who built the grid, and why does it exist? The closer they get to the truth, the more they realize that the grid’s origins are tied to secrets that powerful forces would kill to protect. Packed with conspiracies, shocking revelations, and high-stakes action and with the fate of the Earth hanging in the balance, this miniseries will keep you hooked as the truth about humanity’s biggest safeguard slowly unravels.
Gannibal
With a young girl’s sudden silence, whispers of people being eaten, and a woman whose sinister smile lingers in the shadows, this picturesque village isn’t what it seems, and definitely far from ordinary. In this remote and eerie place, shrouded in unsettling secrets, one police officer stumbles upon a horrifying truth that shakes his very understanding of humanity.
What are the villagers hiding, and why are they so desperate to keep their dark secrets buried? Is the officer ready to face the unthinkable? Or will he become part of the nightmare he’s trying to unravel? One thing is certain: the village hides the true face of evil, and uncovering it may come at the ultimate cost.
From buried secrets to shocking revelations, each series delivers thrills, chills, and moments that stay with you long after the holiday lights dim. So, what are you waiting for? Go ahead, queue up the next episode on Disney+, and keep the suspense alive—because in these worlds, the answers to your questions are always worth it.
